Best waterproof mascaras for when you ugly cry at your wedding

A good waterproof mascara will take you far. There is no shortage of formulas on the market, but for your wedding, you want to be certain you’re only opting for the best.

Weddings bring all kinds of emotions to the surface, and a few tears are practically a given. Whether it’s your partner’s vows, your best friend’s hilarious toast, or that sweet father-daughter dance, the emotions will flow. And while you might feel those joyful tears coming, there’s no reason your mascara has to go with them.

Why Waterproof Mascara Matters

Waterproof mascara is designed to handle the unexpected (or entirely expected) tearful moments on your big day. Its unique formula resists breaking down, standing firm against tears, humidity, and long hours of celebration. Unlike traditional mascara, which can smudge or flake, waterproof versions stay put so you don’t have to worry about raccoon eyes as the emotions flow or the weather turns humid.

The key difference between waterproof and regular formulas lies in their base ingredients. Waterproof mascaras contain film-forming agents and stronger adhesives that create a seal around each lash, providing a water-resistant shield. Regular formulas, on the other hand, often use water-based ingredients that are more prone to smudging. While regular mascara is easier to remove, waterproof options ensure your lashes maintain their length, curl, and volume no matter how emotional or sweaty things get.

Key Features to Look for

• Smudge-resistance. Nothing ruins a photo faster than mascara streaks running down your cheeks. Smudge-resistant waterproof mascaras are crucial for tear-filled moments, keeping your lashes looking flawless. By forming a barrier that repels moisture, they prevent the dreaded raccoon-eye effect, allowing you to stay picture-perfect through every emotional speech and tender embrace.
• Long-wearing. A wedding day is a marathon, not a sprint, and your mascara needs to keep up. Long-wearing formulas ensure that your lashes remain defined and voluminous from morning prep to the final dance, staying fresh throughout the ceremony, reception, and every tearful or sweaty moment in between.
• Comfort. Comfort matters when wearing mascara for hours on end. That’s why it’s important to prioritize hypoallergenic or gentle formulations that won’t irritate your eyes, especially as you’ll likely be blinking back tears. Look for mascaras free of common allergens to ensure comfort during prolonged wear and keep your eyes feeling fresh and ready to sparkle all day long.

The Best Waterproof Mascaras

M·A·CStack Waterproof Mascara
Retail Price: $57

This award-winning mascara is known for being both waterproof and smudge-proof, boasting 24-hour durability. Its clump-resistant formula allows for continuous building, creating gravity-defying volume and instant lash lift. With Drench-Defense Technology, each lash is wrapped in a protective, water-repelling layer, ensuring they’re safe from poolside splashes and emotional tears alike. Build layer upon layer for customizable volume and length with this tear-proof formula.

Maybelline Lash Sensational Washable Mascara
Retail Price: $24.99
Maybelline’s budget-friendly option provides a full-fan effect using a unique fanning brush with ten layers of bristles. Its liquid formula captures each lash from root to tip, revealing layers for an impressive fan-like appearance. Ophthalmologist-tested and suitable for contact lens wearers, this mascara is gentle on sensitive eyes while delivering great results. If you’re looking for an affordable yet reliable mascara that gives a bold, eye-catching look, this is an excellent choice.

Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara
Retail Price: $50
Clinique’s High Impact Waterproof Mascara is perfect if clumpy formulas have been a struggle for you. It features a lightweight consistency with a medium-sized brush that separates and combs through lashes without clumping. One coat provides noticeable definition and length, while additional layers can build smooth volume. Though it’s not the most buildable formula in terms of volume, its lightweight, smudge-proof finish delivers impressive separation, length, and a fluffy, defined look. This makes it a standout choice if you want subtle volume and reliable waterproof performance.

Application Tips for Maximum Longevity

• Lash primer. For a mascara that truly lasts, consider starting with a lash primer. Primers create a smooth, grippy base that helps mascara adhere better to your lashes and enhances both volume and length. Applying a thin layer of primer not only extends the longevity of your mascara but also helps lashes maintain a lifted, defined curl throughout the day. This base coat acts as a protective barrier, preventing smudging and ensuring your lashes remain bold and beautiful.
• Layering. When building layers of waterproof mascara, it’s essential to avoid overloading the brush or letting the first coat fully dry before applying the next. Start with a light coat to define and separate, then gradually add volume with subsequent layers. For maximum impact without clumping, focus on wiggling the brush at the base of your lashes and then comb through to the tips. This technique ensures a smooth, even application that maintains volume and separation.
• Setting spray. After applying your mascara, a light spritz of makeup setting spray can work wonders. This final step adds an invisible shield over your entire face, including your mascara, preventing smudging or flaking while providing extra staying power. Simply hold the bottle about 8-10 inches away and mist evenly to lock in your look. This way, your mascara remains fresh and flawless as you dance, cry, and celebrate through your big day.

Don’t let tears or sweat ruin your bridal glow. With the right waterproof mascara, you can face all the emotional moments and wild dance parties with confidence. Remember, your wedding day is all about enjoying yourself, so why not leave the stress of perfecting your look to the pros? A skilled makeup artist can ensure your mascara is expertly applied and won’t budge all day long. With their help, you can simply savour the joy, knowing your lashes are as flawless as the memories you’re creating. Cheers to celebrating beautifully, without a mascara streak in sight!